Authentic Key Lime Pie Recipe

Key limes are part of the citrus family and are similar to Persian limes. They are the main ingredient in the authentic key lime pie recipe that is made in Key West. Key lime pies are known for their delicious flavor and wonderful texture and are one of the signature desserts found in Key West. Kermit’s authentic key lime pie recipe is still used today and the pies can be found at the Key Lime Shop in Key West.

Authentic Key Lime Pie Recipe

Many people try to replicate the authentic key lime pie recipe from Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe. These are the authentic pies that are simply the best on the planet. They have been recognized by Food Network, National Geographic and others as being the most delicious key lime pies available. We use the highest quality ingredients that we can find to create these delicious and sought-after desserts.

Key lime pies are baked fresh daily. The pie starts with a graham cracker crust which is then filled with delicious key lime filling made with authentic key lime flavor and then completed with wonderful whipped cream to top it off. This is a true delicacy and a taste that will immediately bring you back to the sun and sand of Key West.

Shipment of Key Lime Pies

Kermit’s authentic key lime pies are available for delivery. Pies are shipped on Tuesdays, Wednesdays and Thursdays and are packed securely in dry ice to ensure freshness. You must choose the overnight shipping option for fresh pie deliveries. You may also choose to purchase frozen pies.

You may choose to purchase one pie, two pies or three pies. Key lime pies are 9-inches in diameter and are fresh and ready to eat. There are other options to try as well. You may opt for a gluten-free key lime pie version which is still as delicious as the original. For a tasty variation try the strawberry key lime pie which combines two luscious flavors together in one dessert.

Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe

If you are in Key West you will certainly want to stop by Kermit’s Key West Key Lime Shoppe. Here you will find a complete selection of foods and other items that are made with authentic key limes. The taste is unforgettable and you’ll love the experience of browsing the many selections.

When you leave Key West you’ll want to take a part of the area with you. Shop at Kermit’s for all your souvenir treats as well as plenty of options for you and your family. If you’re craving the key lime flavor and want the authentic taste, visit the online store. We offer a large variety of items that we will quickly ship to you. You will also be able to order our original key lime pies to enjoy with your family as well as a selection of other key lime flavored treats. Visit our website online at to view all of the available options.

Kermit's Key lime Shoppe
(305) 296-0806
200 Elizabeth St, Key West, FL 33040

View Larger Map