Kermit’s Key Lime Pie

(7 customer reviews)


The pie that started it all!  Named the “Best Tasting Key Lime Pie” by Food Network’s Keith Famie’s Adventures, Kermit’s Key Lime Pie is baked fresh daily.  True, tart key lime flavor in a delicious graham cracker crust and topped with fluffy whipped cream, this Key West delicacy will arrive at your door just waiting to be shared with the people who you love the most.

Price of pie includes the cost of the shipping container, dry ice, and the Fed Ex dry ice handling fee.  Overnight shipping charges will be added at checkout.



To insure freshness, pies are ONLY shipped via overnight delivery,  and are ONLY shipped Monday through Thursdays by 2pm EST, for delivery  Tuesday through Friday by 8pm.  If you would like to request a specific date for the delivery of Kermit’s Key Lime Pies, please note your request in the Comment box during check out.

$10.00 Surcharge for any incorrect Delivery Address.  If you do NOT choose an OVERNIGHT option, your pie will NOT be shipped.

Packaged (non-frozen) items cannot be shipped with frozen (pie) items and must be placed on a separate order to ensure safe delivery. Pies and pie bars are delivered to Continental US addresses only.

Be sure of Street Name (Street or Avenue), Number, Apartment, Suite, Floor, City, State , Zip Code. (We verify Zip Codes) Please include your phone number in the space provided on the Checkout form in case there are ANY problems or questions.


Additional information

Weight 6 lbs
Dimensions 13 × 13 × 7 in
Standard 9 inch pies

, ,

7 Replies to “Kermit’s Key Lime Pie”

  1. Kermit’s Key Lime Pies were the best I found in Key West. They had the wonderful true flavor of key limes while others tasted more lemony. The flavor is tart, rich, and suggested that quality ingredients were used throughout. I always look forward to eating one of these pies and experiencing the local flavor.

  2. We tried several Key Lime pies while in Key West. Without a doubt we enjoyed Kermit’s Key Lime pie the best. Highly Recommend. We look forward to ordering pies online to share with our family and friends.

  3. Wow! Requested delivery on the Friday before Father’s Day, and that’s exactly when it arrived, in perfect condition.

    And the pie itself…I’m no KLP expert, but it occurred to me that this was a perfect pie, the gold standard. Perfect in every category- tartness, texture, richness, flavor, sweetness. No take-off points whatsoever. The 5 other people at the table agreed.

  4. I purchase Kermit’s pies every year for my husbands Birthday. This year one pies was damaged in shipment. They not only replaced one they replaced both pies with no questions asked. Thank you Kermit’s for not just wonderful pies but GREAT customer service!!!!

  5. Kermit’s Key Lime Pie. Oh, my. Go by if are in Key West. Order online. Buy juice and make your own. Absolutely fabulous. Made 2 last week and making two more today for Memorial Day. Betty

  6. I’ve ordered from Kermit’s for the past two years now and have never received a pie we didn’t love. It’s impossible to find true Key Lime pie out here in California, so thank goodness I found these guys. I’m about to order another one right now.

Leave a Reply